HMS vs HFSAA: how the two US halal certifiers compare
HMS and HFSAA both certify hand-slaughtered halal meat in the US. Compare who they are, their standards, where they operate, and how to check a listing.
Explainer · By Muslim Built · Updated
What is the difference between HMS and HFSAA?
HMS (Halal Monitoring Services) and HFSAA (Halal Food Standards Alliance of America) are the two best-known US halal certifiers for restaurants and butchers. Both are nonprofits. Both require meat to be hand-slaughtered by a Muslim who says Allah’s name, and both reject machine slaughter. They differ in history, scholarly leadership, and where they operate. Neither is government-run.
Side-by-side comparison
| HMS | HFSAA | |
|---|---|---|
| Full name | Halal Monitoring Services | Halal Food Standards Alliance of America |
| Structure | Nonprofit; a branch of the Shariah Board of America | Registered 501(c)(3); founded by traditionally trained Islamic scholars |
| Base | Chicago, with a New York branch office | Oakland, California (per its New York State registration) |
| Slaughter | Certifies and monitors only hand-slaughtered zabiha meat | Slaughter must be by the hand of a Muslim, not by mechanical means |
| Stunning | Not covered on its public pages; ask HMS directly | Discouraged; only reversible methods allowed where used; captive bolt and irreversible electric bath listed as non-conforming |
| Monitoring | Contract lets HMS randomly inspect meat inventory, premises, invoices, and staff | Scholars take part from board level to day-to-day inspections |
| What it certifies | Slaughterhouses, distributors, groceries, restaurants | Restaurants, meat markets, dining halls, slaughterhouses, plus ingredients and other products |
| Public lookup | City-by-city lists of restaurants and groceries, with a certification number and valid-through date | “Certified Entities” directory and regional chapter pages |
| Cost to consumers | Free | Free |
What does HMS require?
HMS describes its certification as a testimony that a business isn’t mixing hand-slaughtered zabiha meat with other meat. Its zabiha page lists the core conditions:
- At least three of the four main vessels of the throat are cut.
- Allah’s name is said at each slaughter. HMS treats an animal where the tasmiyah is deliberately left out as not halal.
- The slaughterer is a Muslim or a believing person of the Book (Ahl al-Kitab).
- If any condition fails, the meat is not halal.
HMS also says there is no real difference between “halal” and “zabiha halal” for meat. In its view, meat has to meet the zabiha conditions to be halal at all.
What does HFSAA require?
HFSAA’s published standard says the animal must be slaughtered “by the hand of the Muslim slaughterer, and not by machine (mechanical) means.” It discourages stunning. Where stunning is used, the method must be reversible, meaning the animal would recover if it weren’t slaughtered. Captive bolt, controlled-atmosphere stunning, irreversible electric baths, and gunshot are listed as non-conforming. HFSAA also requires every supplier of a certified business to meet the same standard.
Where does each certifier operate?
When we checked in November 2026:
| Muslim Built metro | HMS | HFSAA |
|---|---|---|
| Chicago | Yes (largest network; about 150 certified restaurants across the metro) | Yes |
| New York & North Jersey | Yes (New York City, plus New Jersey) | Yes (New York) |
| Dallas–Fort Worth | Yes | Yes |
| Los Angeles & Orange County | Yes (Los Angeles) | Yes (Los Angeles) |
| Bay Area | Yes | Yes |
| San Diego | Not listed | Yes |
Coverage changes as businesses join or leave. Check the certifier’s site for the latest list.
How do I check an HMS or HFSAA listing?
- Find the certifier’s name on the restaurant’s certificate, decal, or menu.
- Go to hmsusa.org or hfsaa.org and open the city or chapter page.
- Search for the business by name and address. Chains are often certified one location at a time.
- For HMS, check the valid-through date on the listing.
- If the business isn’t listed, treat it as not certified. HFSAA says it won’t comment on businesses outside its list or explain why a certification ended.
Muslim Built imports both public lists. Places on either one get our certified badge, and each listing names the certifier. Read how we verify for details.
Which one should I trust?
Both are widely relied on by Muslims who want hand-slaughtered meat. Some families follow one and not the other because of the scholars behind each, or because of how each handles supplier approval. Muslim Built doesn’t rank them. If it matters to you, ask your local imam, or contact the certifier and ask how it monitors the specific restaurant.
Related reading:
- What “halal certified” means in the US
- Zabiha vs halal: is there a difference?
- How to read a halal certificate
Help us keep this accurate. If a certification is out of date on our site, send a correction.